Choose the stencil that best matches your natural eyebrow shape. Make sure you position the stencil carefully so that your eyebrow is in the middle of the hole. Fill the eyebrow with your chosen colour using a pencil, cream or powder, working from top to bottom so that the colour blends evenly into the eyebrow. Pluck the eyebrow. Use an eyebrow pencil to redraw the arc and tip of the eyebrow.